Tag Archives: father

63. Guest Keri Cain / Father Kim Cain’s Murder Conviction



This episode, Coleman and John have on special guest Keri Cain. Her father Kim Cain was locked up in 1996 for the murder of 71 year old Geraldine Pucillo. She was found in her bathtub on June 13th, 1996 with her hands tied behind her back by a telephone cord and the cause of death was strangulation. There is a lot of evidence involved in this case, but did Kim Cain kill Mrs. Pucillo? Was he involved?

In segment one we chat with Keri and her boyfriend Daryl lightly and share a few laughs. Also Keri tells us about what it was like growing up without her father being there and her initial shock. She informs us of her relationship with her father and how she felt going through all of this.

In segment two, it gets down to what happened that night in June. We discuss the evidence that was key in putting Kim Cain away – The jewelry, the palm print, testimony from Mr. Newton, and much more (also referencing previous coverage of this case on A&E “City Confidential”, Shawn Wasson’s “Millionaire Murder”, and Investigation Discovery’s “Reasonable Doubt” season 2 episode 2).

This episode was so much fun to do and despite bumps in the road we were able to meet up, hangout, chat, and have a great time! We can not thank Keri and Daryl enough for having us over and letting us invade your home and personal space. We hope you guys enjoy as much as we enjoyed recording!